Guest Experience Supervisor

Guest Experience Supervisor Job Locations US-FL-Islamorada

ID 2026-12238

Category Guest Services Position Type Regular Full-Time Overview About CoralTree Hospitality At CoralTree, we serve from the heart — always and in all ways. We believe that genuine connection is what people value most, and we are committed to infusing humanity into everything we do. Our team members are the soul of our company, embodying our core values: Performance | Integrity | Relationships | Empowerment | Innovation | Balanced Life Together, we reimagine the guest experience, drive creativity, and create signature moments that leave a lasting impact. CoralTree manages a curated portfolio of independent hotels, resorts, and residential communities across the United States — and The Islands of Islamorada is one of our most distinctive properties. About The Islands of Islamorada Nestled along the turquoise waters of the Upper Florida Keys, The Islands of Islamorada is a boutique oceanfront resort offering an intimate collection of 22 four-bedroom villas and 8 one-bedroom ocean view suites. Inspired by the natural beauty and cultural richness of the Keys, the resort is a destination for guests seeking immersive coastal experiences — from deep-sea fishing and watersports to curated culinary journeys and wellness retreats. Every detail of the guest experience is thoughtfully crafted to reflect the spirit of the Keys. Position Summary The Guest Services Supervisor is the heartbeat of the front-of-house experience at The Islands of Islamorada. This role is responsible for ensuring seamless, warm, and memorable interactions at every guest touchpoint — from pre-arrival communication and check-in through departure and beyond. The ideal candidate leads by example on the floor, supports and develops the Guest Services team, and embodies the resort's commitment to anticipatory, personalized service. This is a hands-on supervisory role that requires equal parts hospitality instinct, operational precision, and genuine care for people. Responsibilities Guest Experience & Service Delivery Serve as an empowered on-floor leader during assigned shifts, ensuring all guest interactions meet or exceed The Islands of Islamorada service standards. Anticipate guest needs and resolve concerns promptly, professionally, and with genuine empathy — escalating to management when appropriate. Oversee pre-arrival communication and villa/suite preparation coordination, ensuring guest preferences and special requests are confirmed and executed. Conduct property orientation and welcome experiences that reflect the resort's boutique character and Florida Keys spirit. Team Leadership & Development Supervise daily activities of Front Desk Agents and Concierge team members during assigned shifts including check-in/check-out procedures, gift shop sales, room assignments, and billing accuracy. Lead daily pre-shift meetings with the Guest Services team to align on arrivals, special requests, VIP notes, and service priorities. Support the onboarding and ongoing training of new team members, including service standards, PMS systems, and property knowledge. Provide real-time coaching and constructive feedback to team members; recognize and celebrate service excellence. Assign daily tasks, monitor shift productivity, and ensure tasks and checklists are completed accurately and on time. Operations & Administration Maintain thorough knowledge of property amenities, local area attractions, dining, watersports, and experiential offerings to serve as a trusted resource for guests. Coordinate with Housekeeping, Maintenance, F&B, and Recreation departments to ensure smooth interdepartmental communication and seamless service delivery. Monitor villa and suite inventory, manage upsell add-ons/packages, and support the front office's contribution to occupancy and revenue goals. Maintain accurate shift logs and complete required reporting for management review. Support the implementation of resort-wide initiatives including new experiential offerings, seasonal programming, and VIP arrivals. Qualifications Required Minimum 2 years of front desk or guest services experience in a hotel or resort environment, with at least 1 year in a supervisory or lead capacity. Demonstrated ability to lead a team with warmth, professionalism, and clear direction. Proficiency with Property Management Systems (PMS); experience with Infor HMS, Opera, or similar platforms preferred. Exceptional communication skills — written, verbal, and interpersonal — with a natural ability to connect with diverse guests. Strong problem-solving skills and the ability to remain composed under pressure in a fast-paced, high-service environment. Flexible availability including evenings, weekends, and holidays in alignment with resort business demands. Preferred Experience in a boutique, independent, or luxury resort environment with a strong emphasis on personalized service. Familiarity with guest feedback tools (Revinate, TripAdvisor, Google Reviews) and shift communication platforms (Breezeway Messaging or similar). Associate's or Bachelor's degree in Hospitality Management or related field. Bilingual (English/Spanish) a plus given the resort's Keys and Miami drive market guest profile. #LI- Onsite #TheIslandsofIslamorda Options Apply for this job online Apply Share Email this job to a friend Refer Sorry the Share function is not working properly at this moment. Please refresh the page and try again later. Share on your newsfeed Application FAQs Software Powered by iCIMS www.icims.com