Find & Apply For Customer Service Manager Jobs in Worthington, Ohio

About Us Our client is a national, market-leading organization specializing in Employee Benefits, Retirement Plan Administration, Risk Management, and Business Success Services, including HR and Payroll. For over three decades, the organization has helped small and mid-sized businesses succeed by delivering comprehensive solutions designed to strengthen company culture, support employees, and drive business growth. Position Overview We are seeking a positive, energetic, and relationship-driven Client Success Manager to join our client's team! In this role, you will manage and grow a portfolio of existing client accounts, serving as the primary point of contact and trusted advisor. You will work closely with clients to understand their business goals, employee benefit needs, and operational challenges while ensuring they receive exceptional service and support. The ideal candidate is proactive, detail-oriented, and passionate about building long-term client relationships. This individual will help drive client satisfaction, retention, and account growth by identifying opportunities, coordinating solutions, and ensuring client needs are consistently met.

Compensation & Schedule Base Salary:

$50,000-$60,000 annually On-Target Earnings (OTE): Approximately $100,000, including commissions

Commission:

Approximately 2% revenue share on assigned accounts

Commission Payments:

Monthly, typically at the end of the month

Schedule:

Monday-Friday, 8:00 AM-5:00

PM Employment Type:

Full-Time Work Location:

Fully on-site in

Worthington, OH Start Date:

ASAP Commission earnings are based on the revenue generated by the accounts you manage and service. Accounts are initially brought in by Sales Representatives. Key Responsibilities Manage and grow a portfolio of existing client accounts while serving as the primary point of contact. Build and maintain strong, long-term client relationships by understanding each client's business, goals, and employee benefit needs. Lead regular client meetings, check-ins, and strategic planning discussions to support client satisfaction and retention. Coordinate with internal departments, including Benefits, HR, Payroll, Compliance, and Risk Management, to deliver seamless client solutions. Oversee day-to-day client workflows, including compliance requirements, renewals, plan changes, and service requests. Monitor client data, account performance, and industry trends to identify opportunities for improvement and additional services. Identify opportunities to grow existing accounts by recommending relevant products and services that meet clients' evolving needs. Clearly communicate products, services, and value propositions through professional verbal and written communication. Address and resolve client questions, concerns, and service issues promptly and effectively. Maintain accurate account documentation, client notes, and records within internal systems. Stay informed about industry developments, regulatory requirements, and company offerings to provide knowledgeable client support. Qualifications 3+ years of experience in account management, business development, relationship management, customer success, or a similar role. Strong relationship-building skills with the ability to establish trust and maintain long-term client partnerships. Excellent verbal and written communication skills. Strong attention to detail and the ability to maintain accurate account records and documentation. Ability to manage multiple client accounts, prioritize responsibilities, and follow through on commitments. A proactive, client-focused approach to problem-solving and service delivery. Ability to identify opportunities to improve client satisfaction, retention, and account growth. Preferred Qualifications Active Ohio insurance license, such as Life, Health, or Property & Casualty. Benefits & Perks 401(k) with company matching Medical, dental, and vision insurance Company-paid life insurance 8 paid holidays Paid time off, including 10 days during your first year Company-paid TelAssurance with unlimited telemedicine On-site gym Health coaching Interview Process The interview process consists of one in-person interview. If you enjoy building meaningful client relationships, delivering exceptional service, and identifying opportunities to help businesses grow, we encourage you to apply!