Find Jobs
Find Jobs Near You – Available Work in Your Location
Skip to job details
DS
Dutch's Sandwich Shop
Shift Leader / Keyholder - Sandwich Shop - Montclair Indeed fields
Career Insights for Retail Store Shift Supervisor
See where this job fits in the broader career landscape. Knowing your career path helps you see what's possible from here.
Scorecard
Based on New Jersey data
Review key factors to help you decide if this role fits your goals. How is this calculated?
What they do
A Retail Store Shift Supervisor supervises staff at a retail store during a particular work shift. Works at an independent retail business or a store that is part of a large retail chain. Monitors store operations and conditions. Assists as needed with sales and customers and with stocking store merchandise. May be responsible for counting and depositing cash from store registers.
$38,839 / year median in New Jersey
-21% projected decline
Job Description
Shift Leader / Keyholder
- Sandwich Shop
- Montclair Indeed fields Dutch's Sandwich Shop Montclair, NJ Job Details Part-time $20.50
- $22.
ABOUT DUTCH'S
Dutch's is a sandwich shop with locations in Montclair and Hoboken, NJ. We opened Hoboken in February 2026 and it is already our busiest store. A third location is in planning. We are not a chain and we do not run off a microwave. Every item on our menu has a written build sheet- the exact bread, the exact weight, the exact order it goes together in
- and we run a new collab sandwich every single week, which is a big part of why people keep coming back.
WHAT YOU WOULD ACTUALLY DO
Shift Leads are the backbone here. You are the person with the keys.- Open or close the store
- cash-in and cash-out, alarm, temperature logs
- Run the floor during your shift: call the line, keep tickets moving, fix the order that went wrong before the customer has to ask twice
- Execute the prep par sheet, and write the next day's prep list before you leave
- You are one of the only people who can comp, void or discount an order
- always against a reason code. That trust is the job
- Certify-train newer staff on stations alongside the manager
- Step onto any station when someone calls out. Cold line, hot line, breakfast, register
- all four
WHAT WE ARE LOOKING FOR
- 1+ year in a kitchen, deli or cafe
- enough that a rush does not rattle you
- Certified or certifiable on all four stations (we train and test you; that is what the $22.50 is for)
- Cash handling experience and the judgment to be trusted with keys and comps
- Dependable to the point of boring. If you are the person who shows up early, we want you
- Weekend availability
- Friday through Sunday is over half our week
THE SHIFT
We are hiring two Shift Leads in Montclair- one opener, one closer.
Opener:
roughly 5:45 AM- 12:30 PM.
Closer:
roughly 9:30 AM- 4:30 PM.
HOW RAISES WORK HERE
Every raise at Dutch's is tied to a station certification. It is written down, it is the same at both stores, and it is not a favor:- Register / Expo
- $17.00/hr. Day one. No experience needed.
- Sandwich Maker
- $19.00/hr. Certified on Cold Line & Wraps, or Cutlet & Fryer.
- AM Prep / Breakfast
- $19.50/hr. Certified on Breakfast plus par-sheet execution.
- Shift Lead
- $22.50/hr. Certified on all four stations. Keyholder. Cash-handling trained.
- Store Manager
- $64,000 to $68,000 a year.
WHAT YOU GET
- Paid training on every station, on the clock
- A written raise ladder
- certification moves you up, not seniority or who you know
- New Jersey Earned Sick Leave (1 hour for every 30 worked)
- Your schedule published a full week ahead, every Thursday
- Daytime hours. We are a breakfast-and-lunch shop
- no closing at midnight
- Real promotion path: two stores now, a third in planning
HOW TO APPLY
Apply through Indeed. We read every application and we respond either way. If we want to talk, expect a short phone call first, then a paid working interview on the line- you will be paid for that time.
Pay:
$20.50- $22.50 per hour Expected hours: 26.0
- 30.